Huge Corfe Mullen waste dump blamed on Environment Agency delays

More than 28,000 tonnes of waste have accumulated at a quarry near Corfe Mullen in Dorset, with the landowner MB Wilkes attributing the situation to the Environment Agency’s (EA) slow response to repeated permit violations. The building minerals supplier now faces an estimated cleanup cost of around £3 million after waste operator Hillier Recycling, which leased the land, went into liquidation in 2024, abandoning approximately 28,500 tonnes of rubbish on the site. Despite initial concerns raised about the site’s management and the types of waste being deposited within the first year of the lease, the waste kept arriving for several years before the EA finally revoked the permits issued to Hillier.
Paul Wilkes, director of MB Wilkes, expressed his frustration while surveying the extensive piles of rubbish. “Don’t know what to say really. It’s mind blowing,” he told the BBC. He added criticism toward the EA, claiming, “The Environment Agency let it happen.” Hillier Recycling had obtained two permits from the EA to process inert waste such as soil and rubble, as well as commercial and industrial waste. However, within a year, MB Wilkes voiced concerns to the EA urging them to halt tipping activities, but according to Wilkes, “they said ‘don’t worry we’ve got it all in hand’ – and nothing happened.” Waste deliveries continued unabated despite these warnings.
In efforts to prevent further dumping, MB Wilkes’ employees even attempted to block the site entrance with a lorry but were ordered to remove it due to lease conditions. After Hillier Recycling ceased operations and the lease expired, the EA issued a Section 59 notice, compelling the landowner to remove the waste even though MB Wilkes had not been directly responsible for handling it. While the UK’s “polluter pays” principle dictates that those producing waste bear cleanup costs, when a waste operator goes out of business, the responsibility often shifts to landowners. Legal experts have highlighted the difficult position this places on MB Wilkes, who ended up with huge quantities of permitted waste left on their land and no effective enforcement from the EA during the crisis.
Meanwhile, environmental consultants raised serious questions about the EA’s role in issuing and managing the permits. Rebecca Bomers, managing director of Somerton Environmental, criticized the permits granted to Hillier Recycling, stating, “In my opinion, the two permits that were issued here should never have been issued by the Environment Agency in the first place.” She noted the site lacked the required facilities stipulated by the permits, such as buildings to store commercial waste and impermeable surfaces, conditions that “have never been met.” Despite over 20 enforcement visits between 2015 and 2022, and several identified breaches, the EA categorized the site as Compliance Band E—the second lowest rating—yet allowed Hillier Recycling to continue waste handling. Emails even show the EA directing the operator to accept more waste when capacity elsewhere was exceeded, a situation that drew sharp criticism from local MP Vikki Slade and others for the agency’s inadequate enforcement and slow use of regulatory powers
On air now
Low-Fi Lounge