Why children lie and it is important they do

Many parents face situations where their young children deny wrongdoing even when caught red-handed—whether it’s blaming the family pet for scribbles on the wall or inventing ghosts as the culprit when cookies vanish from the jar. While these little fibs might seem troublesome, experts emphasize that such acts of deception actually signal important developmental progress in children’s mental growth.
Clinical psychologist Dr. Jade Redfern discusses in the CBeebies Parenting Download podcast how lying is a skill that children gradually develop and refine. It is not simply negative behavior but rather a complex ability that allows children to navigate social interactions and understand how others think and feel. Research from the University of Bristol highlights that nearly one in four children show signs of understanding some form of deception by as early as ten months old, demonstrating how rapidly these cognitive skills emerge. Professor Elena Hoicka, who conducted the study, shares insight from her own experience as a parent, noting how young children can be surprisingly clever in their attempts to hide actions like sneaking sweets by finding secret spots at home.
The nature of children’s deceit evolves with age. For toddlers around two years old, their falsehoods tend to be quite simple—such as pretending not to hear a request or denying that they have done a forbidden action. As children reach three years of age, their lies become more sophisticated and nuanced, often incorporating an understanding of others’ perspectives. For instance, a child may reveal that a sibling hit them without disclosing that they initiated the conflict, indicating an emerging awareness of “theory of mind” — the ability to appreciate that others have thoughts and intentions distinct from their own. This cognitive leap is a crucial foundation for empathy.
Dr. Redfern explains that children’s motivation to lie often involves self-protection, rooted in a deep attachment to caregivers and the desire to maintain positive relationships. They quickly learn which behaviors foster closeness and which may create distance. Creating a safe and supportive environment where children feel secure in admitting mistakes encourages honesty. Rachel Duffy, recent winner of The Traitors, shares how she tries to foster such honesty with her own children by offering space and reassurance rather than anger when they admit to errors. Redfern notes that occasional white lies—such as politely responding to an unwelcome gift—are a natural part of social learning, especially when met with openness and curiosity from adults, reinforcing empathy and understanding as children mature
On air now
Juicebox