UK news

Letby prosecutors knew expert witness was under investigation

Letby prosecutors knew expert witness was under investigation

In November 2022, Professor Hindmarsh provided testimony during Letby’s trial at Manchester Crown Court, revealing that a child referred to as Child F had experienced dangerously low blood sugar levels over an extended period. He explained to the jury that the baby’s hypoglycaemia, which lasted roughly 17 hours, was unlikely to have been caused by skin injections, as this would necessitate multiple injections. Instead, he suggested that an infusion was “probably the most likely way of achieving the blood glucose effect that we have observed.”

Later, in February 2023, Hindmarsh returned to the court to discuss another case involving a baby identified as Child L, who was on the neonatal unit at the Countess of Chester Hospital in early April 2016. He testified that poisoning was the only plausible explanation for the abnormal blood glucose readings observed in Child L. The baby’s blood sugar levels remained critically low over several days—9th, 10th, and 11th April—even after the intravenous line and nutrient bag were replaced. Subsequent tests showed the infant’s insulin levels were at the maximum measurable limit, leading Hindmarsh, then a paediatric endocrinology expert at University College London, to conclude that “somebody [had] given insulin to [Child L].” Shortly before this testimony, the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) became aware of an investigation by the General Medical Council (GMC).

While the BBC has not confirmed the exact reasons for Hindmarsh’s referral to the GMC, reports from The Guardian revealed the inquiry followed a complaint from Great Ormond Street Hospital, which had ended his contract the previous year. According to CPS guidance issued in 2022, when information emerges that questions the competence or credibility of an expert witness, it is necessary to evaluate the impact of this on past convictions and the methodology employed by the expert. The guidance emphasizes that maintaining public confidence in the criminal justice system is paramount in deciding whether any action should be taken.

The BBC sought clarification from the CPS regarding whether it intended to refer Hindmarsh’s role as an expert witness in the Letby case to its director of legal services but received no response. The CPS clarified that regulatory inquiries, such as those by the GMC, are separate from criminal proceedings and do not automatically affect whether evidence is deemed admissible or reliable. According to The Guardian, when Letby’s defense team first learned of the GMC investigation into Hindmarsh, they chose not to present this information to the jury because the CPS was set to oppose such disclosure, citing the GMC’s lack of a final decision at the time. Furthermore, The Guardian reported that the CPS appeared unaware of an earlier tribunal ruling that had forbidden Hindmarsh from treating patients. The GMC investigation ended without a conclusion because Hindmarsh “relinquished” his registration through voluntary erasure in November 2024. The GMC has not commented in response to the BBC’s inquiries

Read the original at The BBC

On air now

Juice Evenings

PARANOIAHEARTSTEEL, League Of Legends & BAEKHYUN f., tobi lou, OZI & Cal Scruby · Juice Evenings

LIVE