UK news

Swansea glampsite owner appeals £135k legal fees after neighbour sues

Swansea glampsite owner appeals £135k legal fees after neighbour sues

A glampsite owner is contesting a court order requiring her to pay £135,000 in legal fees following a dispute with her neighbours over parking rights on a shared driveway. Carol Esteban attempted to prevent Neil and Nadine Gould from parking their car in their own garden by asserting that their entitlement to use the shared driveway ended directly opposite their front door, which would effectively block their access.

The disagreement escalated with both parties accusing each other of trespassing. Esteban was specifically accused of placing “boulders” to obstruct the Goulds’ entry to the shared track. In 2025, the Goulds initiated legal action against Esteban and won a High Court ruling that allowed them to drive far enough along the shared track to reach their designated parking area. However, Esteban has since filed an appeal against this decision.

Judge Milwyn Jarman’s judgment in July 2025 detailed the situation surrounding the Goulds’ property, Cwmtawe Villa in Abercrave near Swansea, which is completely encircled by land connected to Cwmtawe Farm. Esteban operates a glamping site on this farm, which spans more than 60 acres of ancient woodland and offers individual hot tubs to guests. Historically, the farm and the villa once belonged to the same owner until the villa was sold separately in 1949. Although the records of that sale are missing, a document from 1964 granted an “easement” allowing Cwmtawe Villa’s owners a right of way along a farm-owned track for foot or vehicle access.

The legal conflict arose because an essential letter attached to a map in the 1964 document was missing, leaving the extent of the shared driveway’s easement unclear. Esteban contended that the right of way ended at the gap in a hedge surrounding the villa, arguing that this natural boundary prevented any right of way extending beyond the front door. Judge Jarman dismissed this position, noting that Esteban’s claim could lead to impractical or even absurd outcomes. He ultimately ruled that the Goulds are entitled to use the track up to the northern side of the villa, where they currently park their vehicles. The judge also ordered Esteban to cover the Goulds’ legal costs totaling £135,000.

At the Court of Appeal in London, Esteban’s legal representative, Daniel Bromilow, challenged the High Court’s decision, arguing that Judge Jarman ignored the proper interpretation of the 1949 plans. Bromilow claimed that the judge essentially imposed what he believed the parties should have agreed upon, pointing out that there was no clear evidence showing the right of way extended past the villa’s front door. Additionally, Bromilow contested the costs award against Esteban, citing her partial success in a counterclaim related to an unlawful installation of a waterpipe by the Goulds on her land. Meanwhile, Owen Curry, representing the Goulds, urged the appellate judges to uphold the original ruling, asserting that the High Court judge had reached the correct conclusion. The Court of Appeal has yet to announce its decision

Read the original at The BBC

On air now

Low-Fi Lounge

ForeverDee Dee · Low-Fi Lounge

LIVE