St Mellons fatal crash police officers sacked for lying over searches

Two police officers have been dismissed following a misconduct hearing that found they lied about conducting searches related to a missing persons inquiry. The case is connected to a tragic crash in St Mellons, Cardiff, in 2023, which resulted in the deaths of three individuals. Officers PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone faced allegations of gross misconduct concerning their actions prior to the discovery of a crashed vehicle carrying five passengers.
During the hearing held in Newport, evidence revealed that both officers falsely claimed to have searched the homes of Eve Smith, who died in the crash, and Sophie Russon. These claims were recorded in official police logs and communicated to a senior officer. The panel concluded that the officers’ statements were dishonest, undermining the investigation into the missing persons. Relatives of Eve Smith welcomed the verdict, describing it as “an important step towards accountability.”
Emma Borg, Smith’s mother, expressed how the family had been forced to relive the most painful moments of their lives throughout the proceedings. She noted that their honesty and credibility were unfairly called into question at a time when they depended on the police to carry out their duties properly. Borg emphasized that the dishonesty uncovered by the hearing damaged the integrity of the missing person investigation and eroded the essential trust families place in law enforcement. Smith’s sister, Lauren Doyle, echoed these sentiments, acknowledging the difficulty of enduring years of scrutiny over police decisions but acknowledging the dismissal as a vital milestone in their ongoing pursuit of answers.
Details of the officers’ conduct emerged during the hearing, revealing that Hardwick and Livingstone had visited Russon’s home and later Smith’s residence as part of Gwent Police’s missing person procedures. Despite this, the officers failed to conduct the required thorough property searches intended to gather clues relating to the missing women’s whereabouts. Hardwick logged that a search was completed at Russon’s home and confirmed this to his supervising sergeant and to the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC), which subsequently launched an investigation. However, the officers’ account conflicted with testimony from Russon’s father, Nathan, who said they were at the property only briefly and never requested to search the bedroom.
Livingstone admitted during the hearing that she could not recall whether the searches took place but acknowledged submitting a “poorly written” report, which was deemed deliberately vague yet implied a search had occurred. The misconduct panel found that neither officer had carried out searches at the specified addresses. Hardwick was determined to have made a false entry in the police log and given dishonest statements to both his supervisor and the IOPC. Similarly, Livingstone was found to have submitted false information in the log and to have provided misleading accounts of her actions to her superior.
Ian Arundale, chairing the panel, remarked that the officers’ dishonest behaviour caused significant harm by affecting the family and damaging public confidence in the police service, particularly in a case that attracted substantial public concern. Derrick Campbell from the IOPC criticized the officers for failing to act “honestly and with integrity,” stressing that property searches are a fundamental component of missing person investigations. Campbell highlighted Hardwick’s deliberate falsehoods in police records and communications and noted Livingstone’s failure to clarify details when questioned by the watchdog. Instead of providing an honest account, she claimed not to remember specifics of her visits to the homes of the missing women
On air now
Juice Liverpool