‘Complete reset’ needed to get young people into work, says Milburn review

Former minister Alan Milburn has called for wide-ranging reforms aimed at helping an additional 440,000 young people find employment. Currently, nearly one million individuals aged 16 to 24 in the UK are classified as not in education, employment, or training (NEET), representing approximately 13% of this age group. Milburn’s goal is to reduce this figure to about 5% over the next ten years.
Milburn’s government-commissioned review, set to be published in full soon, advocates for intervention policies stretching from early childhood through to adulthood. These reforms would partly be financed through significant changes to benefits available to young adults. While many recommendations are specific to England, some welfare and tax proposals would apply across the UK’s home nations. Milburn, a former Labour health secretary, emphasizes the urgency of these reforms, warning of a looming “lost generation” and describing the situation as a “moral” crisis. The review highlights a current spending imbalance in 2024/25: for every £1 invested in employment or education support for youth, £25 is spent on youth benefits. By 2036, the review sets a target of reversing this ratio to £2 spent on benefits for every £1 on work support.
Among the review’s major calls for change are specific targets and measures: raising the proportion of children ready for school with basic life skills from 68% to 90% by age five; enhancing the focus on work-related skills in school curricula; providing immediate access to mental health services without requiring a diagnosis; doubling the number of apprenticeships offered to young people; and offering employer incentives such as reduced National Insurance rates for hiring young workers. Central to these changes would be the creation of a “Youth Opportunity Service” in England. This service would assign every young person a dedicated advisor tasked with helping them secure an apprenticeship, college place, supported employment, or job within four months.
To fund these reforms, the review proposes removing eligibility for certain health-related top-ups of Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment (PIP) for young adults, replacing them with a new Youth Allowance and an Additional Cost Allowance for extra living costs. Young individuals unable to work due to severe conditions would receive support through a new Severe and Complex Needs Insurance scheme. Real-life examples reflect the impact of these proposals: Kat, a 21-year-old from Devon with fluctuating health issues, currently relies on Universal Credit with health top-ups but fears a reduction in support under the new system. She expresses a strong desire to work but struggles to find employment that accommodates her health safely.
Milburn notes the frustration many young people face in seeking work opportunities, as illustrated by Josh, a 19-year-old who has spent years searching for a job with the assistance of the youth employment charity Spear. Despite help with applications, Josh experiences repeated rejections or no responses. Grace Coates of Spear St Helens underscores the need for employers to be more willing to hire individuals with limited experience. To encourage recruitment, the review suggests gradually lowering employer National Insurance rates for young workers and maintaining existing initiatives like the Youth Jobs Grant and the Jobs Guarantee. The government has recently shortened the waiting period for young adults to qualify for the Jobs Guarantee from 18 to 12 months on Universal Credit.
Commenting on the proposals, Conservative shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately acknowledged support where Milburn is “right,” but criticized the plans as overly cautious, costly, and unlikely to benefit those currently dependent on welfare. Other responses include Liberal Democrat deputy leader Daisy Cooper’s call for more comprehensive early interventions, such as mandating 100 hours of real work experience and providing each young person with a careers coach. Reform UK’s shadow education secretary Suella Braverman criticized the decade-long timeline, arguing that urgent action is needed to prevent another generation from being “consigned to the scrap heap” and advocated for scrapping the “Labour jobs tax” along with expanding apprenticeships. The Greens’ deputy leader Mothin Ali expressed serious concerns about the approach, advocating alternatives to threatening vulnerable youth with benefit cuts and unsuitable short-term work
On air now
Gentle Juice