Cass report author says she does not support draft conversion practices bill

Baroness Cass, who authored the independent review on gender identity services for young people, has expressed her reservations about the current draft bill aimed at banning conversion practices. Although she initially supported the legislative proposal, she now warns that its present language might lead to “serious unintended consequences” affecting both parents of children experiencing gender distress and medical practitioners involved in their care.
Her concerns were voiced during a parliamentary committee session examining the bill, which the government intends to use to protect LGBT individuals in England and Wales. The government welcomed Baroness Cass’s input, emphasizing their commitment to carefully consider all evidence presented as they aim to “get this ban right.” Conversion practices are understood as attempts—often occurring in religious or familial contexts—to alter or suppress a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity, an experience that can be deeply distressing for those subjected to it.
Baroness Cass highlighted that the bill’s wording requires any victim to have experienced “serious harm to the individual’s physical or mental health, or serious alarm or distress… which has a substantial adverse effect on their usual day-to-day activities.” However, she cautioned that this definition might allow for “vexatious” complaints, potentially putting therapists who work with young people dealing with gender dysphoria at risk of prosecution. She gave an example of a young person who has been sexually abused, noting that therapeutic conversations about such trauma are inherently triggering but crucial for healing. She argued that the current bill’s wording could hinder essential therapeutic work.
Additional worries raised by Baroness Cass include the possible impact on families. For example, if a parent tries to stop a child from purchasing items such as breast binders or hormones, this action might be caught under the bill’s provisions, risking legal consequences. Upon being asked about her earlier support for the legislation, she explained that while she backed the principle, she had not thoroughly reviewed the bill’s details before endorsing it publicly. Nevertheless, in the report she published on gender identity services earlier in 2024, Baroness Cass described conversion practices as “abhorrent” and affirmed her belief that no LGBT person should be subjected to such interventions. She stressed her desire to see a law that safeguards those it intends to help without inadvertently ensnaring others.
The government reiterated its commitment to refining the bill, stating that the draft legislation is currently under pre-legislative scrutiny. They acknowledged Baroness Cass’s recognition of the need to end abusive conversion practices and her caution about avoiding unintended negative effects. The government emphasized their dedication to ending “almost a decade of delay” in providing protections for LGBT+ individuals and assured that all committee evidence will be carefully reviewed as the legislation progresses. The parliamentary committee hearings on the draft bill are ongoing
On air now
Gentle Juice